20.3.2015
News
Competition

KŠB Wins the Philips Cartel Case before the Supreme Administrative Court

The Supreme Administrative Court, which decided the case as the court of last resort, agreed with the key points of KŠB’s argumentation.

The Czech Competition Authority (CCA) alleged that Philips was a party to a cartel agreement between colour TV screen manufacturers. According to the CCA, the cartel existed under both the former and the current (as of 2001) version of the Competition Act. However, unlike the other parties involved in the cartel, Philips was alleged to have been involved only during the period of the “old” Competition Act. Therefore, there was a question concerning when the penalty time limit actually started or, in other words, when Philips’ liability for the alleged cartel involvement ceased. The CCA and the Regional Court in Brno both held that the time limit started when the cartel agreement terminated, i.e. at a time when (as also acknowledged by the CCA) Philips was no longer involved.

However, the Supreme Administrative Court agreed with KŠB’s arguments and overturned the Regional Court’s decision. Given the principle of personal liability, the penalty time limit must have started at the moment the company ceased to be involved in the alleged unlawful activity rather than at the moment the cartel was terminated by all the parties involved. The Supreme Administrative Court held that the penalty time limit had expired even before the CCA started its administrative proceedings and that therefore Philips liability for the alleged competition offence certainly ceased to exist upon the expiry thereof as well. The Supreme Administrative Court thus overturned both the Regional Court’s decision and the CCA’s decision – which did not impose a penalty but ruled that the law was violated – and it ordered the CCA to terminate the proceedings against KŠB’s client.

Other articles

23.10.2025
News

Kyberbezpečnost nově: tisíce firem čekají nové povinnosti. Iniciativa je plně na podnikateli.

Od 1. listopadu 2025 čeká tisíce firem v České republice napříč různými odvětvími zásadní změna v oblasti kybernetické regulace. Nový zákon o kybernetické bezpečnosti spolu s řadou doprovodných právních předpisů totiž výrazně rozšiřuje okruh subjektů, na které bude dopadat. Cílem regulace je zvýšit odolnost technické infrastruktury vůči kybernetickým hrozbám. Místo úzkého okruhu pouze klíčových institucí se nová pravidla budou vztahovat na široké spektrum firem a organizací, které poskytují tzv. regulované služby. Jde o služby zásadní pro fungování společnosti a státu, jejichž narušení či výpadek by mohly mít negativní dopady na bezpečnost státu, ekonomickou stabilitu a každodenní chod společnosti.
20.10.2025
News

KŠB assisted with the financing of the MOSAIQ Beroun project

KŠB provided legal advice to Avisum Beroun, a member of the Go4Home Group, in connection with the financing of the construction of the residential project MOSAIQ Beroun, secured by Trinity Bank.
16.10.2025
News

KŠB becomes the first major independent law firm on the Czech market to implement the Legora AI platform into its practice, symbolically connecting Czech law with global AI innovation

KŠB continues its tradition of being a pioneer of innovation in the field of legal services. As the first major independent law firm on the Czech market, KŠB has started to utilize Legora, an efficient AI assistant developed specifically for legal professionals, a step which will further strengthen our long-term vision – to combine first class legal expertise with modern technologies, thereby allowing us to deliver top-quality legal services to clients even more efficiently.