23.11.2004
News

State Aid – Financing of Promotional Activities by Trade Chambers

Judgment of the Court of Justice in Pearle and Others (C-345/02) of 15 July 2004

Dutch law provides for the establishment of industry associations and entrusts to them a certain scope of internal autonomy. The case concerns a Dutch chamber of traders active on the market of optic products which, by virtue of its internal bye-laws, imposed specific charges on its members. These charges were used solely to finance advertising activity designed to promote optical products for the benefit of the Chamber’ members.

The dispute arose between the chamber and three of its members, private corporations active in the optic industry, which contested the levy of the charge by the chamber. The plaintiffs argued that the charge qualified as state aid within the meaning of applicable Community law. Since the alleged state aid had not been notified to the Commission, as is normally required under Community law, the plaintiff argued that the decision of the chamber to levy the charge was invalid and that the charges already collected were subject to reimbursement.

The Court has ruled in favour of the Chamber. It noted that state aid is defined as any support granted directly or indirectly from public funds, which may be attributed to the activity of public authorities.

That definition does not seem, in the Court’s opinion, to cover the charge collected by the chamber. The revenues so acquired were used only in the interest of the members, which benefited from the promotional activities. Thus, the benefits enjoyed by the members were not related to any allocation or transfer of public funds since any advantages which the members might have obtained were financed by means of the charge collected from them.

The Court also set aside, as irrelevant to this case, the argument that both the activities and authority of the Chamber, including the right to impose charges, were based on the provisions of Dutch public laws on entrepreneurship. The Court also pointed out that the decision of the chamber to impose the charge was taken at the request of some of its members. As such, the charge was not a part of the general policy of the Dutch public authorities and could not have been attributed to them.

Other articles

20.6.2025
News

KŠB advised the seller on the sale of mcePharma to the Brenntag Group

The KŠB team, consisting of Vlastimil Pihera, Jakub Porod, and Dominika Bazalová, provided legal advice to the seller, Mr. Ivan Mikeš, in connection with the sale of 100% of the shares in mcePharma to the international Brenntag Group, a global leader in the distribution of chemicals and ingredients.
18.6.2025
News

KŠB Provided Legal Advisory in the Sale of ARETE Park Rokycany II to the REICO LONG LEASE Fund

Jiří Horník, Jakub Porod, and Yelizaveta Volodina assisted the ARETE group in the sale of the premium logistics complex ARETE Park Rokycany II. The buyer is the REICO LONG LEASE fund, managed by REICO Erste Asset Management. The fund primarily invests in logistics, industrial, retail, office, and other commercial properties, mainly in the Central European region.
17.6.2025
News

KŠB and Smetanova Litomyšl – a partnership with impact

Last weekend, as partners of the Smetanova Litomyšl festival, we had the honour of attending the opening concert of the festival’s 67th edition, featuring the Czech Philharmonic conducted by Jakub Hrůša and the exceptional Norwegian violinist Vilde Frang.